Why Are Dogs Haram But Not Cats? – Dogs, a man’s fine friend… right?
Assalamualaikum, in this newsletter we can explore this debatable topic of whether it’s miles haram or halal to preserve dogs as pets. It appears many are divided on this problem.
For such a subject we can first flip to Quran, next to the hadith, and eventually what 7 scholars have dominated on this.
Hopefully with the aid of the cease of the object you’ll see the different points for and in opposition to and can make your own knowledgeable selection.
Click Here To Find Out : Quran French, The Quran: English Translation, Textual Criticism and Qur’an Manuscripts
Read detailed article about: Labrador Retriever Breed Information and Pictures
QURAN VERSES ON DOGS
Why Are Dogs Haram But Not Cats? There are two mentions of puppies within the Quran. The first is in Surat Al-Ma’idah. In brief, Allah says it’s far permissible to devour that which the dog has looked for you.
“They ask you, [O Muhammad], what has been made lawful for them. Say, “Lawful for you’re [all] appropriate ingredients and [game caught by] what you have educated of searching animals which you educate as Allah has taught you. So devour of what they catch for you, and point out the call of Allah upon it, and worry Allah .” Indeed, Allah is fast in account.” (Quran 5:four)
The 2d point out of Dogs from The Quran is observed in Al-Kahf. In this Surat, it tells a story of a child who turned into covered with the aid of a canine that become guarding the doorway of a cave.
“That changed into from the signs and symptoms of Allah. He whom Allah publications is the [rightly] guided, but he whom He leaves off target – by no means will you discover for him a defensive guide. And you would suppose them unsleeping, at the same time as they were asleep.
And we became them to the proper and to the left, whilst their dog stretched his forelegs at the doorway. If you had checked out them, you would have grew to become from them in flight and been stuffed with the aid of them with terror.” (Quran 18:17-18)
- Surah Al-An’am (6:38): “There is not an animal that lives on the earth, nor a being that flies on its wings, but they are communities like you. We have neglected nothing in the Book, then unto their Lord they (all) shall be gathered.”
This verse emphasizes that all animals and creatures, including cats, are communities in their own right, deserving care and attention from God.
- Surah Al-An’am (6:99): “And it is He who sends down rain from the sky, and We produce thereby the growth of all things. We produce from it greenery from which We produce grains arranged in layers. And from the palm trees – of its emerging fruit are clusters hanging low. And [We produce] gardens of grapevines and olives and pomegranates, similar yet varied. Look at [each of] its fruit when it yields and [at] its ripening. Indeed in that are signs for a people who believe.”
Though not explicitly mentioning cats, this verse speaks about the diversity of God’s creation, including plants and fruits, which indirectly implies the diversity of animals, such as cats.
It’s important to note that the Quran holds animals and their welfare in high regard, emphasizing the responsibility of humans to treat them with care and compassion.
While cats are not specifically mentioned, the general principles of kindness, compassion, and responsible stewardship of animals can be applied to all creatures, including cats.
From these verses it is non-arguable, puppies may be saved for both looking and guarding. The Quran makes no direct assertion for forbidding dogs as pets and handiest has effective things about them.
So how come many Muslims claim dogs are haram? For this we are able to flip to the hadith.
Click Here To Find Out : Online Quran Teacher For Kids and Color Coded Quran , Can Muslim Men Wear Gold?
Are Dog mention in the Quran?
No, dogs are not specifically mentioned in the Quran by name. The Quran does not have explicit verses that refer to dogs. However, there are a few instances where dogs are indirectly mentioned in the Quranic narrative.
In Surah Al-Kahf (The Cave), there is a story about a group of young believers who sought refuge in a cave to escape persecution. The Quran mentions that they had a dog with them in the cave, but it does not go into detail about the dog or its significance in the story. This is mentioned in Surah Al-Kahf (18:18):
“You would have thought them awake, while they were asleep. And We turned them to the right and to the left, while their dog stretched his forelegs at the entrance. If you had looked at them, you would have been frightened by them and turned away from them in flight.”
This mention of the dog in the story serves as a historical narrative rather than a directive or ruling regarding the permissibility of keeping dogs as pets.
It’s worth noting that Islamic teachings primarily come from the Quran and the hadith (sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad).
The guidance regarding dogs and their permissibly as pets or in other contexts is primarily derived from hadith literature and the interpretations of scholars based on those narrations, rather than the Quran itself.
HADITH ON DOGS
Negative Hadith Regarding Dogs
Why Are Dogs Haram But Not Cats? This is in which competition for preserving puppies as pets seem to stem from.
Abu Hurairah (May Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (saws) said, “He who keeps a canine, will lose out of his accurate deeds equal to 1 Qirat every day, besides person who keeps it for guarding the fields or the herd.” [Al-Bukhari and Muslim].
In a any other narration of Muslim, the Messenger of Allah (saws) is said to have said: “He who keeps a dog for any cause other than to guard his property (lands) or his flock of sheep, his true deeds identical to 2 Qirat will be deducted every day.”
The following hadith explains exactly what a qirat is. The Prophet was asked, ‘What are Qirat?’ He replied, “Equal to 2 large mountains.” Related by Bukhari and Muslim.
Ibn Al-Mughaffal mentioned: The Messenger of Allah, peace and benefits be upon him, ordered the killing of puppies after which he stated, “What is the problem with them?
What is the problem with dogs?” Then he granted concession for the usage of dogs for looking and herding. The Prophet said, “If a canine licks your vessel, then wash it seven times and rub it with earth on the eighth time.” Source: Sahih Muslim 280 Grade: Sahih (proper) in line with Imam Muslim
The Prophet (pbuh) stated: “The angels do not enter a house wherein there is a dog or an photograph.”
Grade : Sahih (Darussalam) Reference : Sunan an-Nasa’i 5347 In-e book reference : Book 48, Hadith 308
Positive Hadith Regarding Dogs
Adh-Dhahabi suggested: Fudayl ibn Iyad, may also Allah be thrilled with him, said, “By Allah, it is not lawful on the way to damage a canine or a pig without a just motive, so how will you harm a Muslim?” Source: Siyar A’lam al-Nubalaʼ 8/427
Abu Hurairah (May Allah be pleased with him) suggested: Messenger of Allah (saws) stated, “While a person became strolling on his way he became extremely thirsty. He discovered a well, he went down into it to drink water.
Upon leaving it, he noticed a dog which turned into panting out of thirst. His tongue became lolling out and he become ingesting wet earth from severe thirst.
The man notion to himself: ‘This canine is extremely thirsty as I changed into.’ So he descended into the nicely, stuffed up his leather-based sock with water, and retaining it in his teeth, climbed up and quenched the thirst of the canine. Allah preferred his action and forgave his sins”.
The Companions requested: “Shall we be rewarded for displaying kindness to the animals also?” He (saws) said, “A reward is given in connection with every residing creature” [Al-Bukhari and Muslim] Muttafaqun Alayhi (authenticity agreed upon)
Suggested Read: Is Cutting Your Hair A Sin? , Black Stone Kaaba (Hajr-e-Aswad), Allahumma Innaka Afuwwun Hadith
Summary: Dr.Zakir Naik – His answer begins at 3:30. “In islam retaining dogs is prohibited in your own home as a pet. But maintaining a dog for looking is not any hassle, as guarding your house no hassle”. There is one component I could task Dr.Naik in his solution is in which he says the saliva of the canine can lead to disorder, one in all them is hydrophobia.
Hydrophobia is not a disorder, it’s far surely a phobia or fear specially of water. To say the saliva or lick of a canine will reason ailment is also fake. In reality, in the Quran it even mentions a canine who fetches meat to be permissible to devour. How ought to that be if saliva became entangled on meals?
Summary: Sheikh Assim – It is haram as proudly owning a puppy decreases your deeds by means of qirat (mountain). Secondly, the angels do now not input “a house in which there’s a statue, or a canine, or a portrait”. He maintains on through pronouncing, as Muslims we do no longer need to invite the reasons as to why Allah or the Prophet have advised us what to do.
Majority of the times Allah offers us reasons for forbidding a positive component, in a small variety of instances he might not. This would fall into the small variety of instances. We ought to obey his instructions as Allah is aware of exceptional.
Summary: Bilal Phillips – are we able to hold a dog for protection inside the house? If a canine is kept as a pal or a accomplice it is not allowed. It is authorized if a dog is saved for safety, herding or hunting. If it’s far kept, hold it in a delegated place.
The canine should now not be welcome inside the bedroom where he wakes up licking your face. An interesting observe Bilal Philips makes is a dog who licks the hand of a Muslim would not spoil ablution. The hadith that mentions licking of the ‘vessel’ is regarding meals boxes which could need to be thoroughly wiped clean.
Summary: HUDA TV – Anyone can say I am retaining a canine for protecting motives. But it must be based on needs. “Look on the risk of keeping a canine. It’s ok to hold a cat, cats, kittens, rabits, or whatever” He mentions the hadith announcing it is able to handiest be allowed for safety or for looking. But it have to necessitate an actual want for security.
Summary: Imam Karim Abu Zaid – Dogs aren’t haram. We simply can’t have them within the house because of sanitary issues. It’s also because they prevent angels from entering the house have been a dog is. It can be a number of paintings to clean gadgets seven instances for the whole thing they lick, “puppies are ok”.
He maintains to say Muslims are not anti canine but we on the same time we do now not want to be emotionally engaged hugging and kissing them. We accept as true with in treating them properly and with appreciate. A ladies went to paradise for quenching the thirst of a canine.
Summary: Dr. Shabir Ally – There changed into a sunnah that mentions that Muhammad ordered all dogs to be killed however then made an exception and allowed them for looking and guarding. In making our choice we ought to first hotel to Quran after which Hadith and piece it collectively.
The Quran does no longer mention something negative towards dogs. In truth, it’s simplest positive with the story of a canine who protected the young people within the cave. Some say the saliva is impure however in the Quran it states we are able to eat meat fetched through puppies so that is false.
There is nothing basically impure about puppies from Quranic perspective. It could be traditionally the puppies had been euthanized as they were contagious with rabies however people have forgotten the purpose at the back of why they were killed and attribute it to them being impure. Practically dogs served a purpose. Now those offerings are improved as guide dogs and Muslims need to no longer react so harshly.
Summary: Hamza Yusuf – “The mind-set Muslims have towards dogs is absolutely unacceptable” General message is be fine to dogs, they serve practical cause like a defend dog and seeing eye dog. Many Muslims react very negatively to a Muslim who wants the guiding dog. This is bigoted to him and the dog.
CONCLUSION
Why Are Dogs Haram But Not Cats? Hopefully through this article and my research you’re able to apprehend the specific perspectives and make a selection yourself.
I will bypass the query on to you, do you agree with dogs are haram or halal?
If you enjoyed this text please unfold barakah by sharing it amongst buddies and own family. Also, take into account signing up for our publication and we’ll hold you up to date with modern-day posts.
Click Here To Find Out :: Allahumma Innaka Afuwwun Hadith, Is kissing Haram in Islam?, Can Muslim Men Wear Gold?, Can Muslims Have Dogs?, Tattoos Are Haram in Islam and Allah is The Best Planner
FAQs
Q. Is it haram to buy a cat?
A. No, it isn’t always haram to shop for a cat. Muslims are permissible to purchase a cat to hold as a puppy.
Q. Is it haram to have a cat in the house?
A. No, it is not haram to have a cat inside the residence. Cats are normally considered “smooth” animals and are halal (permissible) to hold inside the house.
Q. Did the prophet Muhammad have a cat?
A. Yes, Prophet Muhammad had a cat named Muezza. He loved the cat and as soon as cut off part of his cloak as opposed to disturb the cat who turned into snoozing on it.
Q. Is it haram to hate cats?
A. Prophet Muhammad loved cats and told his followers to treat them kindly. Therefore, hating cats is not really helpful as it is going in opposition to Islamic teachings.
Q. Are cats haram?
A. No, cats aren’t haram, consistent with Islamic law. Cats have been liked with the aid of the Prophet Muhammad because they had been smooth animals and could be kept in houses.
Q. Cat is halal or haram?
A. Cats are taken into consideration halal in keeping with Islamic regulation due to the fact the Prophet Muhammad loves cats and encourages humans to attend to them.
Q. Are Dogs Haram But Not Cats
No, dogs are not considered inherently haram (forbidden) in Islam. Islam teaches that dogs are permissible to keep as pets or for specific purposes such as hunting, guarding, or assisting individuals with disabilities. However, there are certain guidelines and considerations regarding dogs in Islamic teachings.
Some Muslims follow interpretations that discourage keeping dogs as pets in the house due to concerns about cleanliness and ritual purity. This viewpoint is based on specific hadiths (sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad) that mention purification rituals after coming into contact with a dog’s saliva.
On the other hand, cats are not considered haram in Islam. They are generally regarded as clean animals, and there is no specific prohibition on keeping them as pets. In fact, there are narrations where the Prophet Muhammad showed kindness and affection towards cats.
It’s important to note that the permissibly of keeping dogs or cats as pets may vary among different Islamic scholars and cultural practices.
Muslims are encouraged to seek guidance from knowledgeable scholars and adhere to their interpretations based on their understanding of Islamic teachings.
