Islamic Law – Hadith The Hadith, so long as it is believed to be authentic and verified, is an additional source for Islam and is second only in importance to the Quran. Quran Qur’an tells that the Prophet Muhammad (peace be on his soul), who Allah gave him the Quran to clarify the Quran to people. (An-Nahl 16:44)
Allah will also command us to follow the Messenger, and we can only get Allay’s favor by obeying him obediently. {say, “If you are a lover of God, then follow me, and God will be with you and forgive your wrongs. And God is Forgiving, Merciful. } (Aal Imran 3:31)
Additionally, we find within the Quran:
{It is not for believers, or even an agnostic woman, to decide, when God and His Messenger have ruled on an issue, to make an option to decide on the issue. Whoever refuses to obey God and His Messenger has strayed into a clear error. } (Al-Ahzab 33:36)
Also Read: Quran with urdu translation pdf
Can We Reject a Particular Hadith?
Therefore, it isn’t proper for a religious person to disbelieve in the directive or commandment from the Prophet (PBUH) so long as we are able to verify its authenticity. If you think that a specific tradition is true and believe that the Prophet has declared it, you have the option of accepting the truth of it.
If you doubt its authenticity, or if it contradicts the well-established tenets in the Quran or is irrational, you are not convinced that the Prophet made such a statement, this action will not expel a person from the fold of Islam.
However, if someone is convinced that the Prophet stated this but interprets it differently than the common belief, that is not an act of doubt.
The majority of the traditional beliefs are considered to be isolated traditions. Only one or two percent has been passed down through irrefutable channels.
Suppose anyone does not accept an isolated tradition that is based on solid reasoning and the well-established principles of the Quran (Islamic Law). In that case, It isn’t something that should be regarded as heresy. Plenty of scholars have opposed certain traditions or argued against them.
Suggested Read: Learning Arabic Language of The Quran
Interpreting Controversial Hadiths
The traditions you’ve discussed fall under this category. This means that it is thought shaky and unreliable by a small number of people. However, the second is just advice from the Prophet. The Prophet didn’t think his daughter was in a position to accept having a third spouse.
Anyone who has read the works of tafsir, hadith, and fiqh is aware that the variety of interpretations has been an aspect of the Islamic tradition since the earliest times and continues to the present day. Therefore, nobody should belittle another person for holding an opinion different from theirs.
Suggested Read: wbw quran,
In the end, a person leaves the fold of Islam by refusing to adhere to the basic concepts in Islam, such as the Quran or Sunnah, and Sunnah but not because they have a difference of opinion over minor issues or other specifics.
Almighty Allah knows best.
